PPCdigest.com
← Google Ads questions, answered

Should I pin headlines in responsive search ads?

Rokas Golcas · Updated

Only when a message must appear in every ad, such as a legal disclaimer, required wording or your brand name. Google advises pinning sparingly because it limits the combinations the system can test and can lower Ad Strength. If you do pin, give the position 2 or 3 different headlines and use Headline 1 or 2, which always show.

Pinning fixes a headline or description to one position in your responsive search ad. By default, Google Ads can show your headlines and descriptions in any order, and a pin takes that freedom away for the position you pin.

What happens when you pin?

  • A pinned asset shows only in the position you chose, and other assets can't appear there.
  • Content pinned to Headline position 1, Headline position 2 or Description position 1 always shows. Content pinned to Headline position 3 or Description position 2 isn't guaranteed to show in every ad.
  • If you pin more than one asset to the same position, Google rotates among them.
  • Pinning can lower your Ad Strength, because it limits the combinations the system can test.

Ad Strength itself doesn't decide whether your ad serves: Google says it isn't used to calculate Ad Rank or Quality Score. A lower rating after pinning is a signal that Google has fewer combinations to work with, not a penalty.

When is pinning worth it?

Google's best practices page puts it plainly: for general campaigns, don't pin, and only pin headlines if your campaign goals require consistent messaging. Cases that qualify:

  • Disclaimers. Google's own example: write the disclaimer as a description and pin it to Description position 1 so it appears in every ad.
  • Regulated wording. Industries where certain text must always be visible.
  • Brand or offer that must lead. For example, a brand campaign where every ad should open with the official name.

Headlines that only make sense in a fixed order are another reason people pin, but rewriting them so each one stands alone usually works better.

How do you pin without hurting the ad?

  • Pin 2 or 3 unique options to the same position. Google's example: pin "Official Website" and "The Official Site" to Headline position 1, and every ad starts with one of the two.
  • Avoid near-duplicates in one slot. Google says pinning identical or very similar text to the same position restricts testing and can lower Ad Strength.
  • Keep it to 1 or 2 positions. Leave the rest unpinned so they rotate freely.
  • Use the guaranteed positions. Anything critical goes in Headline 1, Headline 2 or Description 1, never Headline 3.

To pin, open the ad editor, select the pin icon to the right of a headline or description, and choose the position.

My advice: the Ad Strength meter rewards zero pins, but an ad that opens with the wrong message isn't better for it. Pin what has to be there, give that position a couple of variants, and judge the result by conversions rather than by the rating. If you want to know what you're giving up, see how Google chooses which headlines show and whether Ad Strength deserves your attention. For writing the assets themselves, read the ultimate guide to responsive search ads.

Sources