PPCdigest.com
← Google Ads questions, answered

Is it better to have a higher or lower cost per click?

Rokas Golcas · Updated

Neither on its own: a lower cost per click is only better if those clicks still convert. What matters is your cost per conversion, which equals CPC divided by conversion rate, so a higher CPC can be the better deal when those clicks convert at a much higher rate.

A cost per click (CPC) is only half of the math. The other half is how many of those clicks turn into a lead or a sale. Your cost per conversion equals your CPC divided by your conversion rate, so the cheapest click is not always the cheapest customer.

Why can a higher CPC be the better deal?

Here is a simple example with two keywords:

Keyword AKeyword B
CPC$2$6
Conversion rate1%5%
Cost per conversion$200$120

Keyword B costs three times more per click and still brings customers in for less. Searches close to a purchase tend to draw more advertisers, and Google lists the competitiveness of the auction among the factors that set your actual CPC. Position matters too: Google says the thresholds to appear among top ads are generally higher than elsewhere, so top ads typically have higher CPCs than ads lower on the page.

Paying more can also be the right call when it buys volume. For a US consumer services lead-gen account, I grew conversions 54% year over year while CPA rose about 20%. Judged by click or lead price alone, that looks worse. Judged by the number of customers it brought in, it was the better result.

When is a lower CPC actually better?

When it comes from better ad quality, not from cheaper traffic. Google charges you only what is minimally required to clear the Ad Rank thresholds and beat the Ad Rank of the advertiser just below you. Lower quality ads face higher thresholds. Google also says you can win a higher position at a lower price than competitors who bid more by using highly relevant keywords, ads and assets.

A lower CPC is a warning sign when it comes from:

  • broad or irrelevant searches that rarely convert
  • low ad positions that bring fewer and weaker clicks
  • a bid strategy built for traffic when you need sales or leads

Google recommends Maximize Clicks when your goal is website traffic, and Target CPA or Maximize Conversions when your goal is conversions. If you are unsure which fits, see Manual CPC or Maximize Clicks and Maximize Clicks vs Maximize Conversions.

What should you track instead of CPC?

  • Cost per conversion (CPA) for lead generation.
  • Return on ad spend (ROAS) or profit for e-commerce.
  • Conversion rate by search term, so you know which expensive clicks earn their price. My search terms report guide shows how.
  • Quality Score components as a diagnostic, to see whether ad relevance or landing page experience is pushing your prices up. See how Quality Score is calculated.

Use CPC to explain a change, not to judge success. If CPC rises and CPA holds, you are probably buying better clicks. If CPC falls and CPA rises, you are buying worse ones. For the price side of the question, see how much Google charges per click.

Sources